IAALS Appellate Judicial Performance Evaluation Focus Group Report
February 15, 2013
As one of our initial steps in developing recommended tools for evaluating the performance of appellate judges, we convened focus groups of judges and attorneys to identify the responsibilities of appellate judges that should be included in a performance evaluation process and the characteristics of a high-quality appellate opinion.
Leveling the Playing Field: Gender, Ethnicity, and Judicial Performance Evaluation
This study assesses whether, as some claim, there is empirical evidence that women and minority judges are evaluated less favorably than their Caucasian male colleagues. We find that judges in four states with longstanding judicial performance evaluation (JPE) programs generally receive high marks from court users but that there are a few areas in which women and minority judges receive lower scores.
Cornerstones of State Judicial Selection
Laying the Foundation for Quality Court Systems and Judges • June 25, 2012
This publication couples the desired attributes for court systems and individual judges identified by participants in the IAALS Roundtable on Judicial Selection with principles (or “cornerstones”) for judicial selection processes that are most likely to produce court systems and judges with these attributes.
An Opinion on Opinions: Report of the IAALS Task Force on State Appellate Court Opinion Review
The Task Force on Appellate Opinion Review convened by IAALS was charged with considering existing opinion review processes, discussing the merits of various approaches and establishing guidelines and recommendations for both states with existing programs for opinion review and those interested in establishing such a program. Their final report contains broad recommendations, and model criteria and questionnaires.
Goals and Principles for Judicial Nominating Commissions
A subcommittee of the O’Connor Judicial Selection Advisory Committee developed a set of goals to pursue and principles to follow in the selection, composition, and operation of judicial nominating commissions.